Car Key Guide

OEM vs Aftermarket Car Keys

An OEM key is made for the car maker, an aftermarket key by an independent maker, and a refurbished key is a used genuine key rebuilt. Here is which one suits your car.

Updated November 2026, 10 min read By Ben Astle, AutoVault

Every replacement key is one of three things. It comes from the car maker, from an independent maker, or it is a used key rebuilt for a second life. All three can start the car, but they differ in fit, coding and how long they last.

What a new key costs with AutoVault
  • Remote or flip key cut and codedFrom £145
  • Keyless smart keyFrom £150
  • Ford and Transit keysFrom £155
  • Every key lostFrom £180
  • Genuine key from the makerPriced from the registration

These are starting prices with no callout fee. Genuine or aftermarket, the price is given for the key you choose before anyone travels.

Not sure which key your car needs?

Send the registration and a photo of the key, and you get the options for your car with a price for each one.

What Is the Difference Between OEM and Aftermarket Car Keys?

The difference between OEM and aftermarket car keys is who makes them. An OEM key comes from the car maker, or from the firm that builds keys for it, to the maker part number, and an aftermarket key is made by an independent company to fit the same car.

Inside, both carry the same three parts, which are a metal blade, a transponder chip that talks to the immobiliser and, on a remote key, a circuit board that runs the buttons. What changes is how closely those parts match the original, and that is what the table compares.

PointOEM keyAftermarket keyRefurbished key
Made byThe car maker or its supplierAn independent makerThe car maker, then rebuilt
Logo and part numberMaker logo and part numberUsually plain, own part numberOriginal logo on a new shell
ChipNew and unusedNew, matched to the systemUsed, must be reset first
Fit and finishExact matchClose on good keys, poor on low grade onesDepends on the shell fitted
Coding first timeAlmost alwaysUsually, if the key is the right typeOnly if the chip can be reset
WarrantyMaker or dealer parts warrantyFrom the supplier or locksmithFrom the refurbisher, if any
Price of the keyHighestLowerOften the lowest
WaitCan need orderingOften carried in the vanVaries

Cutting and coding cost the same whichever key is chosen, as the work at the car does not change. The saving, when there is one, is on the key alone.

What Is an OEM Car Key?

An OEM car key is a key made by the original equipment manufacturer, the company that supplied the keys fitted to the car at the factory. Sold through the maker, it carries the maker logo and is called a genuine key.

A genuine key is ordered by part number or from the vehicle identification number, so the chip, frequency, buttons and blade match the car exactly. It arrives blank and still has to be cut to the locks and coded to the immobiliser before it does anything.

Two words in online listings are worth reading closely. A key sold as OEM style or OEM quality is an aftermarket key, and a key sold as genuine at a fraction of the dealer price may be a copy or a reject from the factory line.

What Is an Aftermarket Car Key?

An aftermarket car key is a new key made by an independent company to work in place of the original. It is built to the same chip type, frequency and blade profile, but under its own name and usually without the maker logo.

Quality covers a wide range. A good aftermarket key works exactly like the original on most cars, while a low grade one can have a thin shell, buttons that wear through, a short remote range or a board that fails within months.

Aftermarket is not the same as counterfeit. An aftermarket key is sold openly under its own name, while a counterfeit carries a fake maker logo to pass as genuine, which is why the logo alone proves nothing.

What Is a Refurbished Car Key?

A refurbished car key is a used genuine key that has been rebuilt with a new shell, buttons, battery and blade, then sold on for a different car. The electronics are the original ones, which is the appeal.

The catch is the chip. Once a chip has been coded to one car, many types lock to that car for good, and a refurbished key only works on a new car if its chip can be reset first with specialist equipment.

A refurbished key bought ready made is different from having your own key repaired. When your own key gets a new shell or buttons, the chip stays coded to your car and nothing needs resetting.

Is an OEM Car Key Better Than an Aftermarket One?

An OEM car key is better for exact fit and first time coding, but a quality aftermarket key does the same job on most cars for less, so OEM is worth the extra mainly on newer, premium and keyless cars.

When a Genuine Key Is the Better Buy

  • The car is new, leased or still under the maker warranty
  • It uses a keyless smart key with features you rely on
  • The maker locks key supply to its own dealers
  • No aftermarket key exists yet for the model
  • You plan to keep the car for many years

When a Quality Aftermarket Key Is Enough

  • The car is a few years old and out of its warranty
  • You need a spare while one key still works
  • Every key is lost and the car needs to move today
  • The key is a standard chip, remote or flip key
  • The key is supplied and coded by the person who will stand behind it

The deciding factor is rarely the label. A good aftermarket key from a known source beats a doubtful genuine key bought online, and the person who supplies and codes the key matters more than where it was made.

Which Cars Need a Genuine Key?

The cars that need a genuine key are mainly newer premium and keyless models whose security accepts only a part the maker supplies, and Mercedes cars with the FBS4 system from about 2015 are the clearest case.

SituationWhy a genuine key
Mercedes with FBS4, from about 2015Keys are made by Mercedes to order and supplied through a Mercedes dealer
A model launched in the last year or twoAftermarket keys often do not exist yet
Keyless key with extra functionsSome aftermarket versions miss features such as remote start
Lease or company carReturn terms may ask for the keys the car came with
A genuine key already failed to code on a copyRules out the key as the cause

Most cars on UK roads are not in this list. For the common makes and models of the last twenty years, quality aftermarket chip, remote and smart keys are widely made and code like the original.

Can a Used Key Fob Be Programmed to Another Car?

A used key fob can be programmed to another car only when its chip can be reset, which some makes allow and many do not. Whether it works depends on the make, the model and the chip inside.

Used keyWhat usually happens
Many Ford keysThe chip can usually be coded again to another car of the same type
Many Vauxhall, Peugeot and Citroen remote keysThe chip locks to the first car and will not code again
Many Toyota smart keysCan be reset with specialist equipment before coding
Newer keyless keys on premium makesOften locked to the first car for good

A used key listed as tested or working was tested on the car it came from, not on yours. Unless the seller states it has been reset for reuse, treat a used key as one that may never code.

A reset is not always the money saving route either. On some keys the time and equipment cost close to a new aftermarket key, which then comes with no history.

Can a Key Fob From a Different Make or Model Work?

A key fob from a different make or model will not work unless its chip, frequency, part number and blade all match your car, and a look alike shell is no guide to what is inside.

  • Frequency. Cars sold in the UK mostly use 433 MHz, some newer ones 868 MHz, and many cars built for the US or Japan use 315 MHz.
  • Chip. The transponder type has to be one the immobiliser reads, or the doors may open while the engine stays off.
  • Blade. Sister models can use a different lock, so a key that looks right may not go into the door.
  • Buttons. Three buttons on the new key and two on the car leave a button that does nothing, or the other way round.
  • Part number. The number on the back of the key or on the board is the safest match of all.

Imported cars need the most care. A car built for another market can use a frequency or chip that no UK version of the model shares.

What Should You Check Before Buying a Car Key Online?

Before buying a car key online, you should check that it is a complete new key, that its part number, frequency and chip match your car, and who will cut and code it for what total price.

  1. Read the title and the descriptionMany listings are a case only, with no chip or board inside.
  2. Buy new and unusedA used key is only worth buying if the seller states the chip has been reset for reuse.
  3. Match the part numberCompare it with the number on your key or ask for it from the registration.
  4. Match the frequency and chipBoth should be stated in the listing, and a key that claims to fit almost every car is a warning.
  5. Check the bladeMake sure the blade is for your model, not a sister model with a different lock.
  6. Ask about the warrantyFind out who replaces the key if it fails to code or stops working.
  7. Get the total price firstAdd the cost of cutting and coding before deciding the key is a saving.

Signs a Listing Is Not What It Says

  • A maker logo on a key priced far below the dealer
  • No part number, chip type or frequency given
  • Tested and working on a used key with no reset stated
  • Photos that do not show the inside of the key

How Can You Tell if a Car Key Is Genuine?

You can tell if a car key is genuine by its part number, the maker markings on the circuit board and the quality of the finish, not by the logo on the shell, which is easy to copy.

  • A part number moulded or printed on the case that matches the maker records for the car
  • Maker markings on the circuit board, visible once the battery cover is off
  • Sharp, even button symbols that do not rub off
  • A blade that slides or flips with no play and locks firmly in place
  • Weight and feel that match the key that came with the car

A key with a part number the maker does not list for your car is the wrong key, however genuine it looks. A copy can also look identical on the outside and still be built to a far lower standard inside, so the board tells you more than the shell.

Does an Aftermarket Key Affect Your Car Warranty?

An aftermarket key does not on its own end your car warranty. UK competition guidance for the motor trade treats a warranty that demands branded parts for work outside the warranty as a likely problem, yet a claim can still be refused when the fault is caused by the non genuine part.

In practice, a quality key coded by a competent locksmith leaves the rest of the warranty as it was. If a poorly made key were to damage something, that one fault would not be covered. A lease agreement is separate, so read its return terms, as some ask for the keys the car was supplied with.

Do OEM and Aftermarket Keys Both Need Programming?

Yes, OEM and aftermarket keys both need programming, as no new key starts a modern car until its chip is coded to the immobiliser. A genuine key from the maker arrives blank, just like an aftermarket one.

The work is the same for both. The blade is cut to the locks, the chip is coded through the socket under the dashboard, the remote buttons are paired and every key is tested on the car. With mobile car key replacement, all of that happens beside the car and takes from 15 minutes to 1.5 hours on most models.

If a key was lost or stolen, the old key is erased from the car in the same visit, whichever type replaces it. A missing key then stops starting the engine, which a new key on its own does not do.

How Much Does Each Type of Car Key Cost?

A remote or flip key costs from £145 cut and coded with AutoVault, a keyless smart key from £150 and a key with every key lost from £180, while a genuine key from the maker is priced from the registration.

KeyFrom
Spare or replacement remote or flip key£145
Keyless smart key£150
Ford and Transit keys£155
Every key lost£180
Genuine key from the makerFrom the registration

A genuine key costs more because the maker sets the price of the part, and some makes add an order fee and a wait. A key bought online and handed over still needs cutting and coding, so the two totals are the fair way to compare.

Who Can Supply and Code a Genuine or Aftermarket Key?

A main dealer supplies and codes genuine keys, usually with the car at the workshop, and an auto locksmith supplies and codes both kinds at the car. Ben supplies genuine keys or quality aftermarket keys, and the price is given for the key you choose.

Proof the Car Is Yours

Ownership is checked before any key is made. A V5C in your name and photo ID are usually enough, and a recent buyer can show the new keeper slip with the bill of sale.

Every Type of Key

Chip keys, remotes, flip keys, smart keys and key cards are compared in the guide to car key types.

Prices by Make

For starting prices by key type and by make, see what a replacement key costs.

Who Does the Work

Every job is done by Ben Astle of AutoVault, a mobile auto locksmith in Staffordshire with no callout fee.

OEM and Aftermarket Car Key Questions Answered

Buy an OEM key for a new, leased or premium keyless car, and a quality aftermarket key for most cars that are a few years old. On those older cars a good aftermarket key starts the car and works the locks just like the original, for less.

Yes, quality aftermarket key fobs are good and work like the original on most cars. Low grade ones are the problem, with thin shells, weak buttons, short range and boards that can fail within months.

Yes, aftermarket key fobs can be programmed when the chip type, frequency and part number match the car. They are cut and coded with the same equipment as a genuine key.

OEM key fobs are expensive because the car maker sets the price of the part and sells it only through its own parts network, sometimes with an order fee and a wait. The cutting and coding cost the same as for any other key.

A second hand key fob can be reprogrammed only when its chip can be reset, which many Ford keys allow and many Vauxhall, Peugeot and Citroen keys do not. A used key that cannot be reset will never code to another car.

A used key fob cannot be reset at home. Where the chip allows it, a locksmith resets it with specialist equipment before it is coded to the new car, and on many keys no reset is possible at all.

On some older cars the remote buttons can be paired by following a sequence in the handbook, but the chip that starts the engine almost always needs diagnostic equipment. Most cars from the last fifteen years need that equipment for both.

No, an aftermarket key does not on its own void a car warranty in the UK. A claim can still be refused if the fault was caused by the key itself.

A refurbished key can work as well as new when its genuine board is sound and its chip has been reset for your car. When the chip cannot be reset, it will never code, whatever the shell looks like.

Yes, in most cases OEM and genuine mean the same key. A genuine key is sold by the car maker with its logo, and OEM describes the company that made it for the maker. A listing that says OEM style is an aftermarket key.

A quality aftermarket key has the same range as the original when it uses the right frequency. A low grade key can need to be much closer to the car before the doors respond.

Choosing between a genuine and an aftermarket key?

Ring or message with the registration and the key type, and you get the options for your car with a starting price for each, with no callout fee.

Scroll to Top