Car Key Insurance Guide

Does Car Insurance Cover Lost Keys?

Car insurance covers lost keys only when the policy has key cover, built in or added as an extra. Most third party policies leave it out, and many pay for stolen keys only.

Updated November 2026, 10 min read By Ben Astle, AutoVault

Key cover is a separate part of most policies, with its own limit, its own excess and its own rules. This guide shows what to look for in your own documents, and what each route costs.

What to find in your policy
  • Key cover includedYes or no
  • Lost keys as well as stolenCheck the wording
  • Limit per claim or per yearOften £500 to £2,500
  • Excess on a key claimNil to the main excess
  • Effect on the no claims discountVaries by insurer
  • Choice of locksmithYour own or approved only

These are typical ranges across UK policies. Your own schedule and policy wording are the only documents that settle it.

Need a key before the claim is settled?

Ring with the registration and you get a starting price for the job, ready to set against your excess and your limit.

Does Standard Car Insurance Cover Lost Keys?

Standard car insurance does not usually cover lost keys unless key cover is part of the policy. Comprehensive policies are the most likely to include it, sometimes for stolen keys only, while third party policies rarely do.

Type of coverLost keysStolen keys
Comprehensive with key coverUsually covered to a limitUsually covered to a limit
Comprehensive without key coverRarely coveredSometimes, under the main excess
Third party, fire and theftRarely coveredRarely covered
Third party onlyNot coveredNot covered
Standalone key coverCovered to a limitCovered to a limit

Many policies treat loss and theft differently, so look for both words in the key cover section rather than assuming one covers the other.

What Does Key Cover Pay For?

Key cover pays for new keys and the work that makes them start the car, up to the limit in the policy, and many policies add transport and help on the day.

  • New keys cut and coded to the car
  • Coding the immobiliser so the missing keys no longer start it
  • The locksmith callout and getting into the car
  • New locks when the old keys are a security risk
  • A hire car or taxi costs, often capped per day and for a few days
  • A 24 hour helpline
  • House keys on the same ring, on some policies

The limit covers all of these together, so a dear key and a hire car can reach it faster than the key alone.

What Does Key Cover Not Pay For?

Key cover does not pay for keys worn out by normal use, faults in the locks or ignition, extra or upgraded keys, or, on most policies, a stolen key claim without a crime reference number.

Usual exclusionWhat it means for you
Wear and tearA key that fails with age is a repair, not a loss
Faulty locks or ignitionMechanical faults sit outside key cover
Extra or upgraded keysThe policy replaces like with like, not a second spare
No crime reference for a theftA theft not reported to the police is refused
Keys lost by someone outside the householdLending the car can leave a loss uncovered
Claims soon after buying the coverSome add ons have a waiting period at the start
Locks already damaged before the eventDamage that was there before stays yours

How Much Does Key Cover Pay Out?

Key cover pays out up to a set limit, commonly from £500 to £2,500 per claim or per year, and the excess on a key claim ranges from nil on many add ons to the full policy excess when the claim goes through the main policy.

A limit per year can be used up by one large claim, while a limit per claim resets each time. Hire car and taxi costs usually come out of the same limit as the key itself.

When the Excess Cancels the Claim

When the claim runs through the main policy, the excess is taken off the payout first. If the job costs less than the excess, the claim pays nothing at all, so the two figures are worth putting side by side before anyone is called.

Does a Lost Key Claim Affect Your No Claims Discount?

A lost key claim affects the no claims discount on some policies and not on others. Key cover bought as an add on or as a standalone policy is often kept apart from the discount, while a claim under the main policy usually counts against it.

A reduced discount raises the premium at renewal, and that cost can last for several years after the year of the claim. Ask the insurer how a key claim is recorded before you make one, and keep the answer in writing.

Does Breakdown Cover Include Lost Keys?

Breakdown cover includes lost keys on some policies, usually as an optional key cover extra, while basic breakdown cover often pays only to get you into the car or recover it, not for a new key.

Call the breakdown provider before booking anyone else, as most only pay costs they agreed first. Have the V5C and the vehicle identification number ready, as ownership is checked before any work starts.

Home Insurance and Car Keys

Some home contents policies cover car keys under a keys and locks section, often only when the keys were taken from the home. The contents policy wording says whether keys lost away from the house count.

How Do You Check What Your Policy Covers?

You check what your policy covers by reading the key cover section of the policy wording alongside your schedule, which shows whether you bought the cover at all.

  1. Find the schedule and the wordingThe schedule lists the extras you paid for. The wording explains how each one works.
  2. Search for the key sectionLook for key cover, keys and locks, or key protection.
  3. Check lost and stolen separatelyNote whether loss is covered or only theft.
  4. Note the limitWrite down the amount and whether it is per claim or per year.
  5. Note the excess and the no claims positionBoth decide what a claim is worth to you.
  6. Check who does the workSome policies let you choose a locksmith, others send their own supplier.
  7. Check the time limitsMany policies set a deadline to report a loss and a short wait before keys count as lost.

If the wording is unclear, the insurer has to tell you what it covers. A short call before the work is booked saves a refused claim afterwards.

How Does a Lost Key Claim Work?

A lost key claim works by reporting the loss to the insurer, agreeing who does the work, and then either the insurer pays the supplier or you pay and claim the money back with the receipt.

  1. Report the loss quicklySome policies set a deadline, and some wait a day or two before keys count as lost.
  2. Get a crime reference if they were stolenReport the theft on 101 first, as a theft claim is refused without the number.
  3. Agree the work before it startsCosts the insurer did not agree to can be refused.
  4. Have the papers readyThe V5C, the vehicle identification number, a driving licence, proof of address and the policy number.
  5. Keep every receiptThe key, the locksmith, any taxi and any hire car.
  6. Have the missing keys erasedA found key that is no longer coded cannot start the car.

Some insurers send the car to an approved garage and change every lock, which takes longer than a key cut and coded at the car. Ask which route your policy uses if time without the car matters to you.

Claim or Pay Directly? How the Two Compare

The two routes compare on four figures, the cost of the job, your excess, the effect on your no claims discount and how soon you need the car back. The table sets AutoVault starting prices against what a claim would pay at two common excess levels.

JobFromClaim pays with nil excessClaim pays with a £250 excess
Spare key, one key still working£145Up to £145Nothing
New keyless smart key coded£150Up to £150Nothing
Every key lost, new key made, old keys erased£180Up to £180Nothing
Every key lost plus a new ignition barrel£330Up to £330About £80

For keys lost with no spare, the work starts from £180 and is done at the car, usually on the day you call. Prices rise with the make and the key type, so get the price for your own registration before comparing.

Paying directly keeps the event off the policy and the car is often back the same day. Claiming moves the cost to the insurer within its limit and its rules. Which route suits you depends on your own figures.

Is Key Cover Worth It?

Key cover is worth it when one claim is likely to cost more than the premiums and excess you pay along the way, and that depends mostly on the key your car uses and how many keys you hold.

Your situationWhat it means for key cover
Keyless smart key and only one keyA loss costs the most, so cover pays back fastest
Remote key with a working spareA loss costs less, as only a spare is needed
Older car with a plain blade keyA loss costs little, so cover rarely pays back
Cover already in breakdown or home insuranceA second policy may duplicate what you have

Key cover usually costs about £10 to £50 a year. Check every policy you already hold before buying it, as many drivers have it twice without knowing.

Does It Matter If the Keys Were Lost or Stolen?

Yes, it matters, because many policies pay for stolen keys but not lost ones, and a theft claim needs a crime reference number from the police.

A theft claim is also more likely to include new locks, as a thief may know where the car is. A loss with nothing to link the keys to the car usually needs only new keys and the old ones erased. Lost keys do not need reporting to the police unless you believe they were taken.

Who Does the Work When You Claim?

An auto locksmith can do the work whether you claim or pay directly, and many policies let you choose your own locksmith and claim the cost back. AutoVault works at the car across the county as a mobile auto locksmith in Staffordshire, with no callout fee.

Papers for the Insurer

Ask for a written receipt that names the job, the key and the registration, as insurers ask for that detail before they pay.

Choosing Who Makes the Key

A key cover limit is a set sum, so a lower total leaves more of it unused, and the wait and price of each route are set side by side in auto locksmith or main dealer.

Before the Next Loss

Having a spare key cut before you need it is the cheapest protection of all. A second key costs from £145 and turns any later loss into a simple spare key job instead of an all keys lost one.

Car Insurance and Lost Key Questions Answered

Insurance pays for a lost car key only when the policy includes key cover that covers loss as well as theft. Many comprehensive policies with key cover and most standalone key cover do, up to a set limit.

Comprehensive car insurance covers lost keys on some policies, but many cover only stolen keys unless key cover is included or added. The key cover section of the policy wording says which.

No, third party only policies do not cover lost car keys, and third party, fire and theft policies rarely do. Standalone key cover can be bought separately.

Car key cover usually costs about £10 to £50 a year, depending on the insurer, the limit and the type of key it covers.

Many add on key cover policies charge no excess, while a claim under the main policy usually carries the full policy excess. The excess is taken off the payout first.

Claiming for lost keys affects the no claims discount on some policies and not on others. Key cover add ons are often kept separate, while claims under the main policy usually count.

No, a police report is not needed for keys that are simply lost. Stolen keys need a crime reference number, and most insurers refuse a theft claim without one.

Many policies let you choose your own locksmith and claim the cost back with a receipt, while others send their approved supplier. Agree it with the insurer before the work starts.

Key cover pays for new locks on many policies when the old keys are a security risk, which is usually after a theft. Faulty or worn locks are not covered.

An insurance key claim can take from a day to a week or more, as some policies wait before keys count as lost and some send the car to a garage. A key cut and coded at the car is usually done on the day.

Some home contents policies cover car keys under a keys and locks section, often only when the keys were taken from the home. The contents policy wording says whether keys lost elsewhere count.

Lost your car keys?

Ring or message with the registration, and you get a starting price for the job to check against your policy, with no callout fee.

Scroll to Top